Australia rejects US report warning AUKUS will shrink submarine fleet

Sydney, Australia By MonoScoops News Desk
Momentum: 7 out of 10 — an editorial assessment of the story’s impact, reach and velocity, re-assessed as it develops. 7/10Coverage tone — the tone of news coverage on this story: Neutral

Defence Minister Richard Marles said the Congressional Budget Office is wrong to warn that selling Virginia-class submarines to Australia could diminish the US Navy's attack submarine force through 2060.

Australian Defence Minister Richard Marles at the Pentagon in 2023
Australian Defence Minister Richard Marles, who rejected the Congressional Budget Office warning on AUKUS.

Story So Far

Australian Defence Minister Richard Marles has rejected a United States Congressional Budget Office report warning that the AUKUS pact will shrink the US Navy's attack submarine fleet, saying flatly: "They are wrong."

The CBO said in a report this month that selling Virginia-class submarines to Australia could diminish the size of the navy's attack submarine force through to 2060. Marles, speaking in televised remarks on Sunday, said he was not worried about the report "because AUKUS is very much happening" and "the production rate in the United States is absolutely increasing".

AUKUS, Australia's largest-ever defence project, will put US-commanded Virginia-class submarines in Australia from next year, involves selling several of the boats to Australia from around 2030, and will have Britain and Australia build a new class of nuclear-powered submarine. Canberra has committed A$368 billion ($243 billion) over three decades, including billions in investment in British and American production bases. Marles said in October that Australia remained on track to acquire its first nuclear-powered submarines from the US in the early 2030s.

How we know?

The account comes from Reuters' Sydney report, which quotes Marles directly and summarises the CBO finding; the same report was carried unchanged by several outlets. The CBO did not immediately respond to a request for comment outside regular business hours, so its reasoning beyond the finding quoted has not been independently confirmed here. The A$368 billion figure and the 2030 timetable are as stated by the Australian government and in the Reuters report.

Original reporting

Independent corroboration

The exchange matters because AUKUS is the centrepiece of Australia's defence planning and a test of whether American shipyards can build fast enough to supply both navies. Formed in 2021 as part of efforts to counter China's growing influence in the Indo-Pacific, the pact has drawn repeated warnings from Beijing that it is dangerous and could spur a regional arms race. Marles' dismissal of the CBO's warning signals Canberra will not let the report slow the programme.

Keywords

Tags

  • AUKUS
  • Australia
  • submarines
  • defence
  • United States